In 1943 David Karel de Jongh M.D. defended a Ph.D. dissertation on homeopathy, which he ended by concluding that homeopathy should be abolished. He based his judgment on his meticulous examination of many hundreds of articles and books and his experiences while working for quite some time in a homeopathic hospital in Utrecht.
The dissertation is digitised in its entirety, and can be downloaded here. De Jongh’s conclusions are still as valid as ever, as has already been observed by C.P. van der Smagt in his booklet Homeopathie, het wonder van het gelijkende which can be found elsewhere on this site.
Only a few people have any idea of the extent of the messiness and incoherence that is homeopathy. The general public thinks it has something to do with innocuous herbs, and those who know a little more think it is about extreme dilutions.
Similia principle
The core of homeopathy, however, is the similia principle. It was thought up by Samuel Hahnemann in 1796 and went something like ‘if you want to cure a sick person, first you establish their symptoms, and then you search for something that produces the same symptoms in healthy people’. It is unclear how Hahnemann got this idea, but he referred to a 1738 book whose author, Johann Christian Hummel, discusses a Danish army doctor named Stahl, who seemed to be quite famous in Denmark and who explained his own success by stating that the best way to treat the sick was by ‘similia similibus’.
Meer lezen
Vroeger dachten sommigen dat je van hoogspanningslijnen en huishoudelektriciteit kanker krijgt. Er was zelfs een theorie van ene Abraham Liboff (foto) dat bepaalde moleculen in het lichaam konden meetrillen met broodroosters. Na jaren van onderzoek bleek er niets van dat verband tussen huishoudvelden en kanker te kloppen. Ondertussen zijn er tal van rare apparaten ontwikkeld die zogenaamd ziekten kunnen genezen, en die ideeën van Scientology combineren met onzintheorieën. Ze ‘genezen’ met die voorheen enge elektrischedekenvelden. Die heilzame werking wordt ‘verklaard’ door diezelfde Liboff-theorie die eerder vertelde waarom die velden kankerverwekkend waren: de ion cyclotron resonance.
